I want Beef
I thought I live in a secular country. I was wrong.I live on a land where any thing can stir up a revolt, from a word interlocutor to cows. The level of violence rise up with respect to the attachment of the issue with a religion. The reason for this post is the recent issue on banning beef. The government of India decided to introduce a bill banning the sale of beef across India, stating the reason that Cows are sacred for Hindus. They say Cow slaughtering is disturbing the Hindu minds. Fair reason I must say. But if it has to be imposed, we must have a ban on rat poisons too. Rats are sacred too for Hindus. There are temples where they feed rats. So why not a move on that side? We all know this ban is for gaining sentiments for votes! Pure vote bank oriented move.
You may think of me as an extreme anti-Hindu. But wait, by birth I am a Hindu even though I am not a follower of it, or any religion. By this post, I am having no intention to ignite another religious flame war. All I need to say is, if a part of population dont want to have beef, then consider it as their choice. Why should we force the non-followers to follow their practices? I think in all religion, alchohol is disfavoured. Can the government ban Alchohol for this reason? Banking based on interest is not allowed in Islam. Will the government ban banks for this?
The answer will be no. Because it all rests on personal choice. If I believe cows are sacred, I’ll avoid beef from my diet. But I have no right to force my neighbour to stop eating beef. Do I? Do you?
March 9, 2010 - 7:14 am
Fair enough. I am hindu and I eat beef too.
But I don’t understand why ‘secular’ people conveniently ignore the right to read satanic verses, lajja etc. Such things are conspicuously absent from all the secular discussions. Do you think only hindus should adjust and accommodate others? Seriously I fear for the future of our great nation if non-hindus are above all a countability.
March 17, 2010 - 11:45 pm
It’s funny that Hinduism and practises are defined by which part of the country you belong to. When people ask me about Hindus not eating beef, my answer often is that depends on ‘which part of India’s Hindu you call yourself”..Sometimes I feel a Mallu Hindu is like a lovely oxymoron…Mallu Hindu eats beef, does not have a vedic wedding, does not celebrate half the festivals on a north Indian hindu calendar..eats beef with relish…
May 2, 2010 - 3:45 pm
Its cultural invasion… the north indian culture is being imposed upon us..
June 3, 2010 - 10:10 am
Hi,
Fantastic post, I must say.
The govt must also ban pork, because muslims, and some section of christians dont eat.
I like your thought on Rat Poison. Good going.
June 16, 2010 - 11:10 pm
Hi,
mallus without beef!i cant imagine a life without beef
got the message of your post.need people like us to keep India secular.live and let live.